The odyssey movie vs book

Compare and contrast the odyssey book and movie free essays. Some changes were probably made for the cinematic quality of it and the fact that the movie is already 2 hours and 26 minutes, which is pretty long. In the movie version of book ix in the odyssey, polyphemus eats only two men technically we dont see antiphous get eaten, but it is implied that he is, contradicting the storyline which says that he ate six men before odysseus could form a plan to escape. What are the differences between the movie and the book. The telegony aside, the last 548 lines of the odyssey, corresponding to book 24, are believed by many.

Book i athena inspires the prince sing to me of the man, muse, the man of twists and turns driven time and again off course, once he had plundered the hallowed heights of troy. The odyssey 1997, a madefortv movie directed by andrei konchalovsky, is a slightly abbreviated version of the epic. The film stars armand assante as a brooding odysseus, isabella rossellini as a luminous athena, and vanessa williams as a captivating calypso. The odyssey is a fundamental work in the modern western canon, being the oldest extant piece of western literature, second to the iliad. One scene that is different in the movie from the book is when the men are in the cave with cyclops. But in the movie, they are covered with a piece of the sheeps skin. Sing to me of the man, muse, the man of twists and turns driven time and again off course, once he had plundered the hallowed heights of troy. Many think that the movie version of book ix in the odyssey is better than the book. In book 22, he accidentally leaves a weapons storeroom unlocked, a careless. The odyssey is one of two major ancient greek epic poems attributed to homer.

There are also similarities between the conflicts in the movie and book. Every time we watch a movie based on a book we read, we expect it to be just as good as the book. Every book on your english syllabus summed up in a quote from the office. The novel and the movie a comparison a story that describes life style of the early years of the xx century but most importantly that defines the love and survival of two sisters. Overall, the book will always be special to me and it was amazing to see it on a screen, despite if the book. In the book, the men then take the sheep with them, whereas in the movie, they just leave, and taunt poseidon on the way in the book odysseus just calls out to taunt polyphemus.

Continuity is also maintained by using the black monoliths as a thread in the series, as well as by using characters from the previous two novels. Sitting in front of a flatscreen tv while eating popcorn and drinking soda would sound much more appealing than reading a book by the fire at night while drinking. Penelope is another character that is very similar in the book and movie. The three scenes read and viewed were the cyclops, the witch circe, and the land of the dead. However, sitting by the fire, and reading a book in the middle of the night builds up more suspense for us than sitting in the theater watching a movie. In reading the book before seeing the movie the phrase the book is always better than the movie, is proven true with twilight. Some people argue that watching is better than reading but such an argument. The odyssey at a glance cliffsnotes study guides book. As the popular percy jackson series for younger readers attests, kids are fascinated by greek tales of gods, monsters, and heroes, and the odyssey is the original olympian tale. Camerinis movie makes several cuts from the odysseys story, and adds some material. Telemachus never fully matches his fathers talents, at least not by the odyssey s conclusion.

Six differences between the odyssey book and movie in book. Sitting in front of a flatscreen tv while eating popcorn and drinking soda would sound much more appealing than reading a book by the fire at night while drinking a frappucino from starbucks. In some cases, movies and books perform the same function particularly in cases where both the book and the movie are based on similar stories thus have related content. One difference is that in some scenes characters may play different roles or they might just have different ways of doing things. Basically, the movie odyssey keeps many similar aspects in comparison to the epic poem by homer that includes the setting, characters.

After reading the odyssey of homer, you can easily see that the film o brother, where art thou modeled it. Aeneid and the odyssey i chose to compare the odyssey written by the greek poet homer and the aeneid by the roman poet virgil. Although condensed, the film stays mostly true to the spirit of the original work. The book also builds her up as a crack shot, hinted at in the movie but never properly cemented, and she is the one who is tasked with going into the house on neibolt street and delivering a. The adaptation of homers the odyssey ulysses is the latin translation of odysseus, features some pretty cheesy special effects, but is still nonetheless a surprisingly literate version. However, where 2001 is a must, 2061 is seen more as just a pleasant journey through the world of arthur c. The odyssey is a 1997 american mythologyadventure television miniseries based on the ancient greek epic poem by homer, the odyssey. As calypsos husband, odysseus could live forever in divine luxury. I will also tell you there goals, if there similar or different, if or what there obstacles where, and what was there outcome of there journeys. Compare and contrast the book odysseus and the movie o brother where art thou. Now, producers and directors would take successful and famous stories and adapt it into a movie.

I prefer the book, but the novel and movie are very different experiences. In the movie penelope recognizes odysseus right away. For an example, in book 9 of the book he is on this ship with his crew and they. So, i picked odysseus and king leonadis format the movie 300. Stop the insanity of expecting a perfect representation of the book, and you will find that you can enjoy both the book and the movie.

A comparison of the book, the odyssey and the movie. Comparing and contrasing the odyssey movie and book. Sitting in front of a flatscreen tv while eating popcorn and drinking soda would sound much more appealing than reading a book by the fire at night while drinking a. In 1995, director mario camerini released a film adaptation of homers epic poem, which was titled ulysses. They were written and made concurrently, so its not an adaptation of the source.

Before the first strains of richard strauss also sprach zarathustra echoed in movie theaters and the public consciousness for decades to come, 2001. One scene that is different in the movie from the book is when the men are in the cave. For example, odysseuss character is very much the same in the book and movie because he is very smart and witty in battles. For the most part, the movie scenes do a good job of.

Movie after reading the odyssey and watching the movie, i have noticed many differences between the two. Epic poem recently i read the epic poem the odyssey, written by a blind greek prophet, homer and also viewed the movie. The movie is all i hear about and i want to know if u have heard about the book or recommend it. Directed by andrei konchalovsky, the miniseries aired in two parts beginning on may 18, 1997 on nbc. The odyssey is an epic poem written by homer in ancient greece, mostly likely close to the end of the 8th century bc. The odyssey has 24 books, so we analyzed and discussed the arc of the. In our world of advanced technology, we love to watch movies more than we love to read. Features impressive acting by the inimitable kirk douglas as ulysses, and. Posted by kks2301 april 29, 2020 leave a comment on odyssey film vs. In this essay i will be comparing and contrasting the movie ironwill and the book the odyssey. In both versions of the stories, they were very similar. The epic hero, odysseus, overcomes supernatural creatures. Also, in the cyclops scene only one cyclops is shown, in the book many chase the men.

The obstacles that the sisters have to face are very life risking. The odyssey ends as odysseus wins a contest to prove his identity, slaughters the. Whether there are scenes skipped, added, remodified, or they stay the same to one another, both the book and movie of the odyssey share the same story. Movie version essay in our world of advanced technology, we love to watch movies more than we love to read. In the book, the men only turn into pigs, whereas in the movie, they are turned into various animals. The odyssey story is very interesting and fun to learn about.

The film, with kirk douglas as a virile odysseus and anthony quinn as. The differences of the odyssey by homers the odyssey. In 1995, director mario camerini released a film adaptation of homers epic. While odysseus battles mystical creatures and faces the wrath of the gods, his wife penelope and his son telemachus stave off suitors vying for penelopes hand and ithacas throne long enough for odysseus to return.

If you liked this book there is an author interview podcast with the museum of the spy conveniently located in washington, d. It is, in part, a sequel to the iliad, the other homeric epic. What are the differences between the odyssey book and the. The odyssey is the ultimate endorsement of nostos, or homecoming, the idea that a heroic warriors greatest triumph comes when he returns from war to his own home and family. Difference between the odyssey movie and original book cyclopes scene firstly, in the book, it had said that the cyclops was carrying a load of dry boughs on his shoulder when he came in, however, in the movie, he was not carrying anything. Why the odyssey is the perfect book for high school english.

In the book, it says that odysseus tied three sheep with each man. Its a totally different kind of experience, of course, and there are a number of differences between the book and the movie. I will focus my interest on book 11 of the odyssey and book 6 of the aeneid, since that is when both of the main characters make an educational visit to the underworld. In the book, theres a bridging chapter on evolution making the transition from the manapes time to the 21st century and helping tie the theme. He also has a problem with women along his journey back home. Thereon minerva began to tell them of the many sufferings of ulysses, for she pitied him away there in the house of the nymph. Odysseuss trials end with the offer of not one but two alternative wives, and two alternative places to live. Movie vs book essaysdifferent character portrayals from book to film the odyssey, the classic epic by homer, has been retold for centuries since it was first written in. I would say that the movie is very helpful, more helpful than the book. There are many similarities and differences in the odyssey book and movie.

Next, in the book odysseus and his men visit the island of the lotus eater, that does not occur in the film. The odyssey is homers epic of odysseus 10year struggle to return home after the trojan war. Odysseus still faces scylla and charybdis in his long journey home and. What are the differences between the odyssey book and the movie. There is a lot of detail in this book for the armchair historian and professional like. The book is an outstanding read and is not too complicated to enjoy.

Each of these retellings differs from, one another, seeing as each version has a somewhat alternate take on th. Character personality traits and conflicts are very similar between the book and movie of the odyssey. Comparing and contrasing the odyssey movie and book there are many similarities and differences in the odyssey book and movie. Movie vs book essaysdifferent character portrayals from book to film the odyssey, the classic epic by homer, has been retold for centuries. The odyssey isnt just an important book, its also a very exciting book and a beautiful work of literature. What are some differences between the book version of the. Secondly, character personality traits and conflicts are very similar between the book and movie of the odyssey.

It was filmed in malta, turkey, parts of england, and many other places around the mediterranean, where the story takes place. Difference between the odyssey movie and original book. If the iliad is the worlds greatest war epic, then the odyssey is. The shroud that penelope weaves to stall the suitors is not supposed to be for odysseus, but. But in the book it says that he is a person and he has 6 daughters and 6 sons. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. He has a stout heart and an active mind, and sometimes even a bit of a temper, but he never schemes with the same skill or speaks with quite the same fluency as odysseus. Compare and contrast the book odysseus and the movie o.